Locating LAWS: Lethal Autonomous Weapons, Epistemic Space, and “Meaningful Human” Control

Altmann

Jürgen

,

Sauer

Frank

.

2017

. “

Autonomous Weapon Systems and Strategic Stability

.”

Survival

59

(

5

):

117

–

42

.

Anderson

Kenneth

,

Waxman

Matthew C.

.

2013

. “

Law and Ethics for Autonomous Weapons Systems: Why a Ban Won't Work and How the Laws of War Can

.”

The Hoover Institution Jean Perkins Task Force on National Security and Law Essay Series WCL Research Paper 2013-11, 1–32

.

Arkin

Ronald C.

2009

. “

Ethical Robots in Warfare

.”

IEEE Technology and Society Magazine

28

(

1

):

30

–

33

.

Arkin

Ronald C.

.

2010

. “

The Case for Ethical Autonomy in Unmanned Systems

.”

Journal of Military Ethics

9

(

4

):

332

–

41

.

Article 36

.

2013

. “

Killer Robots: UK Government Policy on Fully Autonomous Weapons

.”

London. Accessed March 19, 2021. https://article36.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Policy_Paper1.pdf

.

Asaro

Peter

.

2019

. “

Algorithms of Violence: Critical Social Perspectives on Autonomous Weapons

.”

Social Research: An International Quarterly

86

:

537

–

55

.

Barnett

Michael

.

2017

. “

Hierarchy and Paternalism

.” In

Hierarchies in World Politics

, edited by

Zarakol

Ayşe

,

66

–

94

.

Cambridge

:

Cambridge University Press

.

Blaney

David L.

,

Tickner

Arlene B.

.

2017

. “

Worlding, Ontological Politics and the Possibility of a Decolonial IR

.”

Millennium

45

(

3

):

293

–

311

.

Blount

Clive

.

2011

. “

War at a Distance? Some Thoughts for Airpower Practitioners

.”

Air Power Review

14

:

31

–

39

.

Bode

Ingvild

,

Huelss

Hendrik

.

2018

. “

Autonomous Weapons Systems and Changing Norms in International Relations

.”

Review of International Studies

44

(

3

):

393

–

413

.

Bode

Ingvild

,

Watts

Tom

.

2021

.

Meaning-less Human Control: Lessons from Air-Defence Systems on Meaningful Human Control for the debate on AWS

.

Odense

:

University of Southern Denmark in collaboration with Drone Wars

.

Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela on Behalf of the Non-Aligned Movement and Other Parties to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons

.

2018

. “

General Principles on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems

.”

United Nations Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons Group of Governmental Experts CCW/GGE.1/2018/WP.1. Accessed May 18, 2021. https://reachingcriticalwill.org/images/documents/Disarmament-fora/ccw/2018/gge/documents/GGE.1-WP1.pdf

.

Bourke

Joanna

.

2017

. “

Theorizing Ballistics: Ethics, Emotions, and Weapons Scientists

.”

History and Theory

56

(

4

):

135

–

51

.

Brazil

.

2019a

. “

Military Applications—Agenda Item 5(c)

.”

United Nations Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons Group of Governmental Experts CCW/GGE.1/2018/WP.1. Accessed May 18, 2021. https://reachingcriticalwill.org/images/documents/Disarmament-fora/ccw/2019/gge/statements/25March_Brazil 5d.pdf

.

Brazil

.

2019b

. “

Possible Options for Addressing Laws—Agenda Item 5(e)

.”

United Nations Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons Group of Governmental Experts CCW/GGE.1/2018/WP.1. Accessed May 18, 2021. https://reachingcriticalwill.org/images/documents/Disarmament-fora/ccw/2019/gge/statements/27March_Brazil5e.pdf

.

Buzan

Barry

,

Lawson

George

.

2015

.

The Global Transformation: History, Modernity and the Making of International Relations

.

Cambridge

:

Cambridge University Press

.

Cameron

David

.

2015

. “

ISIL in Syria

.”

House of Commons Debate, December 2, 2015. Hansard Vol. 603 col. 323–500. Accessed May 18, 2021. https://hansard.parliament.uk/Comons/2015-12-02/debates/15120254000002/ISILInSyria

Çapan

Zeynep Gülşah

.

2017

. “

Writing International Relations from the Invisible Side of the Abyssal Line

.”

Review of International Studies

43

(

4

):

602

–

11

.

Crootof

Rebecca

.

2016

. “

War Torts: Accountability for Autonomous Weapons

.”

University of Pennsylvania Law Review

164

:

1347

–

1402

.

Cummings

M.L.

2019

. “

Lethal Autonomous Weapons: Meaningful Human Control or Meaningful Human Certification?

”

IEEE Technology and Society Magazine

38

(

4

):

20

–

26

.

https://futureoflife.org/open-letter-autonomous-weapons/?cn-reloaded=1

Future of Life Institute

.

2015

. “

Autonomous Weapons: An Open Letter from AI and Robotics Researchers. Future of Life Institute

.”

Accessed June 11, 2020

.

Garcia

Denise

.

2018

. “

Lethal Artificial Intelligence and Change: The Future of International Peace and Security

.”

International Studies Review

20

(

2

):

334

–

41

.

Getachew

Adom

.

2019

.

Worldmaking after Empire: The Rise and Fall of Self-Determination

.

Princeton, NJ

:

Princeton University Press

.

Gill

Amandeep Singh

.

2019

. “

Artificial Intelligence and International Security: The Long View

.”

Ethics & International Affairs

33

(

2

):

169

–

79

.

Gong

Gerrit

.

1984

.

The Standard of Civilization in International Society

.

Oxford

:

Oxford University Press

.

Gregory

Derek

.

2011a

. “

The Everywhere War

.”

The Geographical Journal

177

(

3

):

238

–

50

.

Gregory

Derek

.

2011b

. “

From a View to a Kill: Drones and Late Modern War

.”

Theory, Culture & Society

28

(

7–8

):

188

–

215

.

Gregory

Thomas

.

2017

. “

Targeted Killings: Drones, Noncombatant Immunity, and the Politics of Killing

.”

Contemporary Security Policy

38

(

2

):

212

–

36

.

Group of Governmental Experts on Emerging Technologies in the Area of Lethal Autonomous Weapons System

.

2021

. “

Chairperson's Summary

.”

United Nations Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons Group of Governmental Experts CCW/GGE.1/2020/WP.7. Accessed May 18, 2021. https://reachingcriticalwill.org/images/documents/Disarmament-fora/ccw/2020/gge/documents/chair-sumary.pdf

.

Haas

Michael Carl

,

Fischer

Sophie-Charlotte

.

2017

. “

The Evolution of Targeted Killing Practices: Autonomous Weapons, Future Conflict, and the International Order

.”

Contemporary Security Policy

38

(

2

):

281

–

306

.

Haner

Justin

,

Garcia

Denise

.

2019

. “

The Artificial Intelligence Arms Race: Trends and World Leaders in Autonomous Weapons Development

.”

Global Policy

10

(

3

):

331

–

37

.

Harari

Yuval Noah

.

2018

. “

Why Technology Favors Tyranny

.”

The Atlantic. Accessed November 13, 2020. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/10/yuval-noah-harari-technology-tyranny/568330/

.

Heyns

Christof

.

2013

. “

Report of the Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial, Summary or Arbitrary Executions

.”

United Nations Human Rights Council, New York

.

Heyns

Christof

.

2017

. “

Autonomous Weapons in Armed Conflict and the Right to a Dignified Life: An African Perspective

.”

South African Journal on Human Rights

33

(

1

):

46

–

71

.

Himmelreich

Johannes

.

2019

. “

Responsibility for Killer Robots

.”

Ethical Theory and Moral Practice

22

(

3

):

731

–

47

.

Hobson

John M.

2004

.

The Eastern Origins of Western Civilization

.

Cambridge

:

Cambridge University Press

.

Hobson

John M.

.

2012

.

The Eurocentric Conception of World Politics: Western International Theory, 1760–2010

.

Cambridge

:

Cambridge University Press

.

Horowitz

Michael C.

2016a

. “

The Ethics & Morality of Robotic Warfare: Assessing the Debate over Autonomous Weapons

.”

Daedalus

145

(

4

):

25

–

36

.

Horowitz

Michael C.

.

2016b

. “

Public Opinion and the Politics of the Killer Robots Debate

.”

Research & Politics

3

(

1

):

1

–

8

.

Horowitz

Michael C.

.

2019

. “

When Speed Kills: Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems, Deterrence and Stability

.”

Journal of Strategic Studies

42

(

6

):

764

–

88

.

Human Rights Watch

.

2012

.

Losing Humanity: The Case against Killer Robots

.

Washington, DC

:

Human Rights Watch

.

Human Rights Watch

.

2016

.

Making the Case: The Dangers of Killer Robots and the Need for a Preemptive Ban

.

New York

:

Human Rights Watch

.

Human Rights Watch

.

2020a

.

New Weapons, Proven Precedent: Elements of and Models for a Treaty on Killer Robots

.

Washington, DC:

Human Rights Watch

.

Human Rights Watch

.

2020b

.

Stopping Killer Robots: Country Positions on Banning Fully Autonomous Weapons and Retaining Meaningful Human Control

.

Washington, DC

:

Human Rights Watch

.

Hurd

Ian

.

2017

. “

Targeted Killing in International Relations Theory: Recursive Politics of Technology, Law, and Practice

.”

Contemporary Security Policy

38

(

2

):

307

–

19

.

Ikenberry

G. John

.

2001

.

After Victory: Institutions, Strategic Restraint, and the Rebuilding of Order after Major Wars

.

Princeton, NJ

:

Princeton University Press

.

Jensen

Benjamin M.

,

Whyte

Christopher

,

Cuomo

Scott

.

2020

. “

Algorithms at War: The Promise, Peril, and Limits of Artificial Intelligence

.”

International Studies Review

22

(

3

):

526

–

50

.

Johnston

Patrick B.

2012

. “

Does Decapitation Work? Assessing the Effectiveness of Leadership Targeting in Counterinsurgency Campaigns

.”

International Security

36

(

4

):

47

–

79

.

Johnston

Patrick B.

,

Sarbahi

Anoop K.

.

2016

. “

The Impact of US Drone Strikes on Terrorism in Pakistan

.”

International Studies Quarterly

60

(

2

):

203

–

19

.

Jones

Emily

.

2018

. “

A Posthuman-Xenofeminist Analysis of the Discourse on Autonomous Weapons Systems and Other Killing Machines

.”

Australian Feminist Law Journal

44

(

1

):

93

–

118

.

Jones

Emily

.

2019

. “

Feminist Technologies and Post-Capitalism: Defining and Reflecting upon Xenofeminism

.”

Feminist Review

123

(

1

):

126

–

34

.

Keal

Paul

.

2017

. “

Beyond 'War in the Strict Sense'

.” In

The Globalization on International Society

, edited by

Dunne

Tim

,

Reus-Smit

Christian

,

165

–

84

.

Oxford

:

Oxford University Press

.

Keene

Edward

.

2002

.

Beyond the Anarchical Society: Grotius, Colonialism and Order in World Politics

.

Cambridge

:

Cambridge University Press

.

Keene

Edward

.

2014

. “

The Standard of ‘Civilisation’, the Expansion Thesis and the 19th-century International Social Space

.”

Millennium

42

(

3

):

651

–

73

.

Keohane

Robert Owen

.

1984

.

After Hegemony: Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy

.

Princeton, NJ

:

Princeton University Press

.

Kirkpatrick

Keith

.

2016

. “

Can We Trust Autonomous Weapons?

”

Communications of the ACM

59

(

12

):

27

–

29

.

Li

Ni

,

Huai

Wenqing

,

Wang

Shaodan

.

2017

. “

The Solution of Target Assignment Problem in Command and Control Decision-Making Behaviour Simulation

.”

Enterprise Information Systems

11

(

7

):

1059

–

77

.

Ling

L.H.M

.

2014

.

The Dao of World Politics: Towards a Post-Westphalian, Worldist International Relations

.

Abingdon

:

Routledge

.

Ling

L.H.M.

,

Nordin

Astrid H.M.

.

2019

. “

On Relations and Relationality: A Conversation with Friends

.”

Cambridge Review of International Affairs

32

(

5

):

654

–

68

.

Liu

Hin-Yan

.

2019

. “

From the Autonomy Framework towards Networks and Systems Approaches for ‘Autonomous’ Weapons Systems

.”

Journal of International Humanitarian Legal Studies

10

(

1

):

89

–

110

.

Maas

Matthijs M.

2019

. “

Innovation-Proof Global Governance for Military Artificial Intelligence? How I Learned to Stop Worrying, and Love the Bot

.”

Journal of International Humanitarian Legal Studies

10

(

1

):

129

–

57

.

Manchanda

Nivi

.

2017

. “

Rendering Afghanistan Legible: Borders, Frontiers and the ‘State’ of Afghanistan

.”

Politics

37

(

4

):

386

–

401

.

McDougall

Carrie

.

2019

. “

Autonomous Weapons Systems and Accountability: Putting the Cart before the Horse

.”

Melbourne Journal of International Law

20

(

1

):

58

–

87

.

McMahan

Jeff

.

2013

.

Killing in War

.

Oxford

:

Oxford University Press

.

Mignolo

Walter D.

,

Walsh

Catherine E.

.

2018

.

On Decoloniality: Concepts, Analytics, Praxis

.

Durham, NC

:

Duke University Press

.

Morgan

Forrest E.

,

Boudreaux

Benjamin

,

Lohn

Andrew J.

,

Ashby

Mark

,

Curriden

Christian

,

Klima

Kelly

,

Grossman

Derek

.

2020

.

Military Applications of Artificial Intelligence: Ethical Concerns in an Uncertain World

.

Santa Monica, CA

:

RAND Corporation

.

Neocleous

Mark

.

2013

. “

Air Power as Police Power

.”

Environment and Planning D: Society and Space

31

(

4

):

578

–

93

.

Niva

Steve

.

2013

. “

Disappearing Violence: JSOC and the Pentagon's New Cartography of Networked Warfare

.”

Security Dialogue

44

(

3

):

185

–

202

.

Nordin

Astrid H.M.

,

Graham M.

,

Smith

,

Raoul

,

Bunskoek

,

Chiung-chiu

,

Huang

,

Yih-jye (Jay)

,

Hwang

,

Patrick Thaddeus

,

Jackson

,

Emilian

,

Kavalsky

et al.

2019

. “

Towards Global Relational Theorizing: A Dialogue between Sinophone and Anglophone Scholarship on Relationalism

.”

Cambridge Review of International Affairs

32

(

5

):

570

–

81

.

Nyholm

Sven

.

2018

. “

Attributing Agency to Automated Systems: Reflections on Human–Robot Collaborations and Responsibility-Loci

.”

Science and Engineering Ethics

24

:

1201

–

19

.

Obama

Barack

.

2014

.

Statement by the President on ISIL.

Washington, DC

:

The White House

.

O'Driscoll

Cian

.

2008

.

The Renegotiation of the Just War Tradition and the Right to War in the Twenty-First Century

.

New York

:

Palgrave Macmillan

.

O'Hagan

Jacinta

.

2017

. “

The Role of Civilization in the Globalization of International Society

.” In

The Globalization of International Society

, edited by

Dunne

Tim

,

Reus-Smit

Christian

,

185

–

203

.

Oxford

:

Oxford University Press

.

O'Hagan

Jacinta

.

2020

. “

Shape Shifting: Civilizational Discourse and the Analysis of Cross-Cultural Interaction in the Constitution of International Society

.”

Journal of International Political Theory

16

(

2

):

190

–

209

.

Page

James Michael

.

2016

.

Afghanistan: An Analytical Framing—Past, Present and into the Future

. In

DGSi Working Papers

.

Durham

:

Durham Global Security Institute

.

People's Republic of China

.

2018

. “

Position Paper

.”

United Nations Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons Group of Governmental Experts CCW/GGE.1/2018/WP.7. Accessed May 18, 2021. https://reachingcriticalwill.org/images/documents/Disarmament-fora/ccw/2018/gge/documents/GGE.1-WP7.pdf

.

Phillips

Andrew

.

2014

. “

Civilising Missions and the Rise of International Hierarchies in Early Modern Asia

.”

Millennium

42

(

3

):

697

–

717

.

Phillips

Andrew

.

2016

. “

Global IR Meets Global History: Sovereignty, Modernity, and the International System's Expansion in the Indian Ocean Region

.”

International Studies Review

18

(

1

):

62

–

77

.

Price

Bryan C.

2012

. “

Targeting Top Terrorists: How Leadership Decapitation Contributes to Counterterrorism

.”

International Security

36

(

4

):

9

–

46

.

Price

Bryan C.

.

2019

. “

Terrorism as Cancer: How to Combat an Incurable Disease

.”

Terrorism and Political Violence

31

(

5

):

1096

–

1120

.

Qin

Yaqing

.

2018

.

A Relational Theory of World Politics

.

Cambridge

:

Cambridge University Press

.

Rigterink

Anouk S.

2020

. “

The Wane of Command: Evidence on Drone Strikes and Control within Terrorist Organizations

.”

American Political Science Review

115

(

1

):

31

–

50

.

Robillard

Michael

.

2018

. “

No Such Thing as Killer Robots

.”

Journal of Applied Philosophy

35

(

4

):

705

–

17

.

Rodin

David

.

2014

.

The Ethics of War and Peace

.

Farnham

:

Ashgate

.

Roff

Heather

.

2016a

. “

To Ban or Regulate Autonomous Weapons

.”

Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists

72

(

2

):

122

–

24

.

Roff

Heather M.

2016b

. “

Gendering a Warbot

.”

International Feminist Journal of Politics

18

(

1

):

1

–

18

.

Roff

Heather M.

,

Danks

David

.

2018

. “

‘Trust but Verify’: The Difficulty of Trusting Autonomous Weapons Systems

.”

Journal of Military Ethics

17

(

1

):

2

–

20

.

Rosert

Elvira

,

Sauer

Frank

.

2019

. “

Prohibiting Autonomous Weapons: Put Human Dignity First

.”

Global Policy

10

(

3

):

370

–

75

.

Santos

Boaventura de Sousa

.

2017

.

Epistemologies of the South: Justice against Epistemicide

.

London

:

Routledge

.

Santos

Boaventura de Sousa

.

2018

.

The End of the Cognitive Empire: The Coming of Age of Epistemologies of the South

.

Durham, NC

:

Duke University Press

.

Satia

Priya

.

2014

. “

Drones: A History from the British Middle East

.”

Humanity: An International Journal of Human Rights

5

:

1

–

31

.

Schmitt

Michael N.

2013

. “

Autonomous Weapons Systems and International Humanitarian Law: A Reply to the Critics

.”

Cambridge, MA

:

Harvard National Security Journal

.

Schwarz

Elke

.

2018

.

Death Machines: the Ethics of Violent Technologies

.

Manchester

:

Manchester University Press

.

Shah

Aqil

.

2018

. “

Do U.S. Drone Strikes Cause Blowback? Evidence from Pakistan and Beyond

.”

International Security

42

(

4

):

47

–

84

.

Shahi

Deepshikha

,

Ascione

Gennaro

.

2016

. “

Rethinking the Absence of Post-Western International Relations Theory in India: ‘Advaitic Monism’ as an Alternative Epistemological Resource

.”

European Journal of International Relations

22

(

2

):

313

–

34

.

Shaw

Ian G.R.

,

Akhter

Majed

.

2012

. “

The Unbearable Humanness of Drone Warfare in FATA, Pakistan

.”

Antipode

44

(

4

):

1490

–

1509

.

Sparrow

Robert

.

2007

. “

Killer Robots

.”

Journal of Applied Philosophy

24

(

1

):

62

–

77

.

Sparrow

Robert

.

2016

. “

Robots and Respect: Assessing the Case against Autonomous Weapon Systems

.”

Ethics & International Affairs

30

(

1

):

93

–

116

.

www.e-ir.info/2020/04/15/guiding-principles-for-the-development-and-use-of-laws-version-1-0/Last

Sri Lanka

.

2017

. “

General Exchange of Views: Statement by Sri Lanka

.”

United Nations Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons Group of Governmental Experts. Accessed May 18, 2012. https://reachingcriticalwill.org/images/documents/Disarmament-fora/ccw/2017/gge/statements/13Nov_SriLanka.pdf

.

The Canberra Working Group

.

2020

. “

Guiding Principles for the Development and Use of LAWS: Version 1.0

.”

e-International Relations, April 15, 2020. Accessed December 2, 2020

.

.

United States

.

2002

.

The National Security Strategy of the United States of America

.

Washington, DC

:

Executive Office of the President of the United States

.

United States

.

2006

.

The National Security Strategy of the United States of America

.

Washington, DC

:

Executive Office of the President of the United States

.

United States

.

2010

.

The National Security Strategy of the United States of America

.

Washington, DC

:

Executive Office of the President of the United States.

United States

.

2015

.

The National Security Strategy of the United States of America

.

Washington, DC

:

Executive Office of the President of the United States

.

United States

.

2017

.

The National Security Strategy of the United States of America

.

Washington, DC

:

Executive Office of the President of the United States

.

http://www.dtic.mil/whs/directives/corres/pdf/3000009p.pdf

United States Department of Defense

.

2012

. “

Autonomy in Weapons Systems

.”

Directive No. 30000.09, Washington, DC. Accessed February 28, 2021

.”

.

Verdiesen

Ilse

,

Santoni de Sio

Filippo

,

Dignum

Virginia

.

2019

. “

Moral Values Related to Autonomous Weapon Systems: An Empirical Survey that Reveals Common Ground for the Ethical Debate

.”

IEEE Technology and Society Magazine

38

(

4

):

34

–

44

.

Vitalis

Robert

.

2015

.

White World Order, Black Power Politics: The Birth of American International Relations

.

Ithaca, NY

:

Cornell University Press

.

Waltz

Kenneth N.

1979

.

Theory of International Politics

.

Boston, MA

:

McGraw-Hill

.

Walzer

Michael

.

2006

.

Just and Unjust Wars: A Moral Argument with Historical Illustrations

, 4th ed.

New York

:

Basic Books

.

Williams

Alison J.

2011

. “

Enabling Persistent Presence? Performing the Embodied Geopolitics of the Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Assemblage

.”

Political Geography

30

(

7

):

381

–

90

.

Williams

John

.

2015a

. “

Democracy and Regulating Autonomous Weapons: Biting the Bullet while Missing the Point?

”

Global Policy

6

(

3

):

179

–

89

.

Williams

John

.

2015b

. “

Distant Intimacy: Space, Drones, and Just War

.”

Ethics & International Affairs

29

(

1

):

93

–

110

.